Post ID: 97788, posted on December 6th, 2014
I'm not a really great cutter with my knife, and I struggle with this same thing, but when you really relax and focus you can cut really straight. I think that the more this is practiced with a good, sharp knife (and polystyrene will really dull your blade) it'll become easier and easier.
I guess I wanted to think that as long as I lay a straight edge with a t square I'd suddenly have a nice straight cut without effort, but it still is an 'art skill' to do so.
One major thing that helped me out was to do a very, very light score along the straight edge with the knife first, making sure to keep it perpendicular to the floor and pressed against the straight edge. Then make a second cut a bit deeper, this helps keep the blade on the path without diverting off to the side or angling away.
If i'm really nervous about getting the cut straight I just keep making slightly deeper and deeper passes. If you go in really deep it is very easy to angle the blade away and extend the cut out away from the straight edge, or dig in at a side angle.
I know I kept seeing all these videos where people will just swipe their hand and they magically have a perfect cut in all sorts of things, saws, x-acto knives etc, but when I got to doing it myself I found it was anything but easy and requires a bit of practice for those clean results.